Trader Joe's vs. Aldi vs. Lidl: Which Has the Cheapest Groceries in NYC?

Based on 2 items priced at all three chains' NYC locations in the last 30 days, Lidl came out cheapest overall — winning on 1 of 2 items head-to-head.

Based on 36,386 community-submitted NYC price reports from the last 30 days. Last updated October 7, 2026.

Head-to-head basket total (2 shared items)

Trader Joe's

$6.39

cheapest on 0/2

Aldi

$1.88

cheapest on 1/2

Lidl

$1.74

cheapest on 1/2

Item-by-item price comparison

Item	Trader Joe's	Aldi	Lidl
🍩Donuts(per 6 pack)	$4.78	$3.29	—
🍞Sourdough Bread(per loaf)	$3.80	$3.49	—
🥤Ginger Ale (2L)(per 2L bottle)	$10.62	$2.69	—
🫙Kombucha(per 16 oz bottle)	$3.49	$1.99	—
💧Sparkling Water (12 pk)(per case)

Frequently asked questions

Is Lidl cheaper than the other two in NYC?

Based on 2 grocery items priced at all three chains' NYC locations in the past 30 days, Lidl had the lowest total cost ($1.74 for the basket), and was the single cheapest option on 1 of 2 items.

Does Lidl have locations in New York City?

Yes — Lidl operates locations across NYC, including Manhattan and Queens. Prices vary by location, unlike Trader Joe's and Aldi, which price items the same at every US store.

Are Trader Joe's and Aldi prices the same at every location?

Yes. Both chains use uniform nationwide pricing, so a price reported by a shopper at one NYC location reflects the price at every Trader Joe's or Aldi location.

Where do these prices come from?

Every price on this page is submitted and verified by real NYC shoppers via Cheapr NYC, based on 36,386 price reports in the last 30 days, most recently updated October 7, 2026.

Explore further

Methodology: prices are self-reported by NYC shoppers and verified through Cheapr NYC's community verification process. Trader Joe's and Aldi price items identically at every US location, so a single NYC report reflects the chain nationwide; Lidl prices vary by location and are averaged across Lidl's NYC stores. Only reports from the last 30 days are included.